Where is the cheapest two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?

Saint George has the lowest median two-bedroom apartment rent in Staten Island at $1,750/month — 34% below the borough median.

Where is the most expensive two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?

Eltingville has the highest median two-bedroom apartment rent in Staten Island at $4,425/month — 67% above the borough median.

Is $2,650 a normal rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?

Yes — $2,650 is the median, meaning half of two-bedroom apartment listings in Staten Island ask for less and half ask for more. Anything from $1,710 (10th percentile) to $4,425 (90th percentile) is within the normal range. Prices outside that range are either deals worth grabbing or overpriced outliers.

How do I find a two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?

Set a Leaseswap alert for Staten Island two-bedroom apartments under your budget. You'll get notified within minutes when new listings post on StreetEasy, LeaseBreak, NYBits, and more — before they get flooded with applications.

Staten Island rent data

Average 2-Bedroom rent in Staten Island

The median two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island rents for $2,650/month as of September 2026. Prices range from $1,710 (Saint George) to $4,425 (Eltingville) across 7 neighborhoods.

17 listings
7 neighborhoods
Updated September 2026

The short answer

A two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island costs a median of $2,650/month as of September 2026, based on 17 current listings across 7 neighborhoods. The cheapest neighborhood is Saint George at $1,750/mo, and the most expensive is Eltingville at $4,425/mo. The middle 80% of neighborhoods rent between $1,710 and $4,425.

Price distribution

How 7 neighborhoods stack up

Each bar shows how many neighborhoods fall inside that rent band. The borough median sits at $2,650/mo.

$1,750–$2,085

$2,420–$2,755

$3,425–$3,760

$4,095–$4,426

Median bucket highlighted in gold. Source: active NYC rental listings.

2-Bedrooms by neighborhood

Neighborhood	10th %	Median	90th %	Listings
Saint George	$1,710	$1,750	$4,110	3
Westerleigh	$2,248	$2,500	$2,695	6
Great Kills	$2,519	$2,599	$2,760	3
Castleton Corners	$2,450	$2,650	$2,850	2
South Beach	$2,750	$2,750	$2,750	1
Arrochar	$3,599	$3,599	$3,599	1
Eltingville	$4,425	$4,425	$4,425	1

FAQs

Common questions

What is the average rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?: The median rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island is $2,650 per month as of September 2026, based on 17 current listings across 7 neighborhoods. The bottom 10% of neighborhoods rent for under $1,710, and the top 10% exceed $4,425.
Where is the cheapest two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?: Saint George has the lowest median two-bedroom apartment rent in Staten Island at $1,750/month — 34% below the borough median.
Where is the most expensive two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?: Eltingville has the highest median two-bedroom apartment rent in Staten Island at $4,425/month — 67% above the borough median.
Is $2,650 a normal rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?: Yes — $2,650 is the median, meaning half of two-bedroom apartment listings in Staten Island ask for less and half ask for more. Anything from $1,710 (10th percentile) to $4,425 (90th percentile) is within the normal range. Prices outside that range are either deals worth grabbing or overpriced outliers.
How do I find a two-bedroom apartment in Staten Island?: Set a Leaseswap alert for Staten Island two-bedroom apartments under your budget. You'll get notified within minutes when new listings post on StreetEasy, LeaseBreak, NYBits, and more — before they get flooded with applications.